Absolutely clear blue sky in South Somerset this morning so I took a photo of a neighbour's sunflower peering over the garden wall.
In the evening there was a pleasing cloudscape as sunset approached.
Absolutely clear blue sky in South Somerset this morning so I took a photo of a neighbour's sunflower peering over the garden wall.
In the evening there was a pleasing cloudscape as sunset approached.
My late grandfather was a regular in the Somerset Light Infantry, but during the First World War he was transferred to the Royal Tank Corps and took part in the Battle of Cambrai where tanks were first used successfully, and en masse.
Therefore I was interested to
see in the press that there are those in our Conservative government who
advocate abandoning the use of tanks in the British Army. I came across an article and a letter in The Week (5 September) which argued for
and against the retention of the tank.
The case against was made by
Jack Allen, a former Cold War tank commander, in an article originally
published in Reaction. Life. I reproduce the points I found of interest
below:
Tanks for the memory, not
for war today.
MBTs were already proving
ineffective when I was a tank commander at the end of the Cold War: they’re
even more so today. For a start, being
huge (some weigh 70 tons) they’re hard to move around the battlefield, hard to
hide from drones and attack helicopters, and notoriously bad at fighting in
cities. On the modern battlefield –
think Iraq or Syria – they’re easy prey to the lone operator on a moped with an
anti-tank gun. Or to roadside IEDs. Even if the attacks only damage a tank, it
all adds to the vast amount of support needed to keep the tanks on the
road. It’s not as if NATO general staff
believe the next conflict will be fought on the open North European Plain,
where MBTs come into their own. No,
Moscow prefers to work by destabilising governments and infiltrating
militias. By all means let’s invest in
light armoured vehicles. But let’s ditch
the tank.
The case for retaining tanks
was originally made in The Times.
I reproduce it below as published in The
Week.
Why tanks are vital.
To The Times.
In all the articles (about
the rationale for scrapping tanks), we could find no mention of
deterrence. Is there anyone left in
Whitehall who understands deterrence strategy, which we are all signed up to in
NATO? Simply put, it requires an ability
to outdo an enemy at all levels of conflict up to and including nuclear; if you
can’t do this at each level, with a reasonable level of assurance, the strategy
loses credibility. The test for
disposing of a capability that an enemy might retain is whether whatever is
deemed to be a replacement will deter that enemy. If not, then escalation or capitulation are
the only responses.
When our conventional forces
are as limited in number compared with those of our potential enemies as they
now are, escalation could quickly rise towards a nuclear conflict. Under these circumstances, our nuclear
capability might well become a cuckoo in the nest.
Air Chief Marshall Sir Michael Graydon; Vice Admiral
Sir Jeremy Blackham.
Without a big increase in
attack helicopters to replace the tanks, I lean towards agreeing with Sir
Michael and Sir Jeremy.
The epitaph on his gravestone includes the description “A good egg”.
Charles Thomas Dennehy “Sox” Hosegood FRAeS is best
remembered for his career in aviation.
He joined the Royal Navy just after the outbreak of World War Two and
gained his Fleet Air Arm wings in July 1940.
Late in the war he was one of the first six Naval Pilots sent to America
to convert to helicopters on the Sikorsky R4.
In March 1945 Hosegood became the Navy test pilot at the Joint Service
Helicopter Test Unit of the Airborne Forces Experimental Establishment (AFEE)
at Beulieu. He left the Navy in November
1946.
In 1952 Hosegood became Chief Test Pilot of the Bristol
Aeroplane Company’s Helicopter Division.
He worked on the Bristol Sycamore, the first British helicopter to gain
its Certificate of Airworthiness. He
made the initial flights of the Bristol Belvedere and saw it into service with
the RAF.
After Westland took over Bristol’s Helicopter Division in 1963 Hosegood joined the South Western Electricity Board to set up their Helicopter
Unit for power line inspection duties.
He managed the Helicopter Unit for 20 years up to his retirement by
which time it had expanded to cover power line inspections for 4 neighbouring
Boards.
He is buried in the churchyard of Christ Church in the
village of Redhill, North Somerset.
Source:
As readers of this blog may have noticed I enjoy photographing churches and wandering around churchyards. I am obviously stating the obvious, but there is history inside the church as well as outside where the locals are laid to rest. Churches with their nineteenth century and earlier architecture make wonderfully picturesque photos, and when exploring a churchyard I always find something of interest whether it be a grave of a notable local or an interesting epitaph on a headstone.
An English town or village
would not be the same without its church so it is sad to see that many churches
are now unused. Thankfully, many have
been taken over by various church conservation trusts, and they do a fine job
in preserving them.
| The Church of St. Thomas in the Somerset village of Thurlbear. It is in the care of the Churches Conservation Trust. |
Therefore I was disappointed
to read an article in the 8th of August edition of The Week.
It suggests that the Church of England will become more remote from
its parishioners resulting in fewer active churches – no doubt more will
regrettably close. I reproduce the
article, first published in The Daily
Telegraph, below.
The C of E is killing off the
parish church.
Giles Fraser
The Daily Telegraph
The parish church – “for centuries
the bedrock of the Church of England’s engagement with communities throughout
the land” – is dying, says Giles Fraser.
It’s not just secularisation that’s killing it, but the controlling
nature of Church leaders. As a recent
piece by Revd Stephen Trott in The Church
Times pointed out, the rot set in back in the 1970s, when the assets of
individual parishes were effectively nationalised by the General Synod. This enabled money to be redistributed from
wealthy parishes to smaller ones, but it also spawned a burgeoning central
administration that has since employed ever more accountants, administrators
and archdeacons. Ever fewer communities,
meanwhile, have their own vicar. Covid
has accelerated this trend, with talk of digital aids such as zoom reducing the
need for “analogue priests”, and the Archbishop of Canterbury ordering parish
clergy not to enter their own churches over Easter to pray. Such centralisation is a “recipe for
institutional collapse”. “The hastening
death of the parish will tear the beating heart from many a small place that is
reliant upon church to help organise its common life.”
I was struck by the beauty of the late evening sky over South Somerset on the 8th August about half an hour before sunset.
The mares' tails were fascinating.